Star Trek Lower Decks Talk Through

Hosted ByBrian Meloche & Kyle McAdams & Laurence Todd

Edit here

STLDP 009 – Crisis Point (S1E9)

The Star Trek: Lower Decks Talk Through
Star Trek Lower Decks Talk Through
STLDP 009 - Crisis Point (S1E9)

Star Trek: Lower Decks – Season 1 Episode 9 – Crisis Point

We’re back with the ninth and penultimate episode of Season 1 of Star Trek: Lower Decks, titled Crisis Point. This episode was written by story editor Ben Rodgers and directed by Bob Suarez, who also directed S1E3 Temporal Edict and S1E6 Terminal Provocations. Joining us this week is a special guest, LT from NC!

Mariner again taking charge when she shouldn’t…

The cold open starts with a scene where we see Mariner violating the Prime Directive. She takes charge but avoids rules she shouldn’t. It really sets up the end of this episode. However, Freeman offers a compromise that effectively ends the reptiles (Selay?) overthrowing the rats (Anticans?) by offering food replicators. I did get a laugh out of the lizards wanting to bask, and how they taste delicious.

Boimler’s simulation taken over…

Boimler goes out of his way to kiss butt. LT made a really good observation during the podcast on how Boimler seems to be able to handle interactions with the other ensigns but clams up whenever someone has a higher rank. Boimler, as usual, tries to come up with the perfect answer for Freeman by studying how she reacts to answers, instead of doing what he should be doing, and answer for himself.

Mariner really IS messed up…

Of course, when Mariner discovers this is a “perfect” simulation, she re-programs it to become a movie, with her as the villain. This movie turned out to be better therapy than the food metaphors spouted from Dr. Migleemo. She ends up facing off with herself. This was both interesting and shows how messed up she is. I hope that she worked out things like it seemed she did. She really is the only one that casts herself as the villain. She really is capable of being an exemplary officer if she applies herself and stops taking short cuts.

The budding Rutherford/Billups bromance…

The Rutherford/Billups scenes were funny. There was a budding bromance, reminiscent of Laforge and Data, or O’Brien and Bashir, but unrequited at this point. I think they could have explored that a bit more in real life.

Tendi explains why she’s not part of the Orion Syndicate…

Some Orions haven’t been thieves for over five years! So I guess Orion is not part of the Federation, but some have left to join Starfleet. Mariner did program her to be the stereotypical Orion, something she didn’t appreciate, but she appreciated Mariner getting into this movie even less.

So now he knows…

I thought it was funny when Boimler ran out of the Captain’s Ready Room screaming like a ninny, as Freeman says he came in unprepared. In actuality, he clammed up after discovering the big secret about Mariner, that she is Captain Freeman’s daughter. What he does with that secret is anyone’s guess. It seems like we’ll know in a few days.

Best episode so far!

We all agreed that Crisis Point was the best episode of the season. It did go heavy on the references again, almost exclusively from the movies, but they were appropriate both to the story and the situation. This season really seems ready to end on a high note. Will they stick the landing? Tune in next week!


00:00:00 STLDP 009 – Crisis Point (S1E9)
00:00:21 Intro
00:02:26 Feedback for Previous Episodes
00:07:22 About Crisis Point
00:08:39 Ratings
00:11:29 Yeses
00:28:55 Nos
00:33:37 Not Good Enoughs
00:35:05 Listener Feedback
00:46:25 Spot the References
00:53:05 Our Notes
01:10:52 Shipwide Announcements
01:20:11 Wrap Up

We should be back to a regular schedule so the deadline for feedback will be on Fridays going forward…

We did not extend the deadline this week! For our next episode, we’ll be discussing the Season 1 Episode 10 of Star Trek: Lower Decks, titled No Small Parts. The deadline will be 7 PM Eastern/6 PM Central on Friday, October 9, 2020, unless announced on the Facebook group otherwise. Your feedback is SO important to us!!! And don’t forget to sign up for our Patreon to get access to our Patreon episodes.

Links to us…

Want to participate? Join our Facebook group! And follow us on Twitter! And don’t forget to subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts! While you do, we’d appreciate it if you can leave us a review, hopefully, a 5-star! Or, if not, a rating will do!!! You can do the same on Podchaser. Also, you can leave us a review on the Talk Through Media Facebook page.

Sign up to CBS All Access! Help support the podcast! If you sign up from this link, you’ll help support the podcast, as CBS gives us a small referral fee, and it costs you nothing!

Star Trek: Lower Decks is now streaming on Paramount Plus! Click this banner to sign up, and you’ll help support the podcast!

Speaking of our Patreon…

We have released our eighth Patreon call Sunday, September 27th, where we talked Lower Decks, the upcoming Season 3 of Discovery, and quite a lot about Deep Space Nine. If you want to listen to it when it comes out, sign up to our Patreon! for as little as $1/month and you’ll get access!

Become a Patron! Podchaser - The Star Trek Picard Cast Podchaser - The Star Trek Discovery Podcast, featuring Star Trek: Picard
Watch this episode on YouTube!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.